Not guilty verdicts on sex workers’ allegations

June 23, 2014 | By More

jury-boxA jury has thrown out kidnapping, rape, and sexual violation charges where the alleged victims were two Christchurch sex workers.

The 29-year-old Nelson man, Daniel Juan Daly, who has been on trial in the High Court at Christchurch for the past six days was convicted only of assaulting one of the sex workers.

Justice Rachel Dunningham remanded him on bail for sentence on that charge on August 14.

She thanked the jury members for their work on a difficult trial. “Your job is now done and you are free to return to your normal lives,” she told them.

They had deliberated for six hours on the original 13 charges. One sexual violation charge was dropped on Friday, after they asked a question about the evidence relating to it, and they reached not guilty verdicts on 11 more today.

Justice Dunningham asked for a pre-sentence report, including a report on Daly’s suitability for home or community detention, and a victim impact statement from the sex worker.

All charges had related to alleged incidents in Christchurch on the night of January 24-25, 2013, involving two women he had met for sex.

Daly acknowledged that sex had taken place, but denied that the violent offending occurred. The court heard of a dispute about the amount of money offered and paid for the sex.

The Crown alleged he had unlawfully detained the first woman, sexually violated her, and assaulted her using a knife as a weapon. There were not guilty verdicts on all those charges.

The charges involving the second woman alleged rape, several sexual violations, unlawfully detaining her, and assaulting her. The jury found that only the assault charge was proved, and acquitted Daly on all the rest.

Both women gave evidence during the trial, and recordings of their interviews with the police – in which they made the allegations – were played to the jury.

Matt Dixon and Moana Cole of the Public Defence Service appeared for Daly.

Cross-examined by Mr Dixon, the second woman told of agreeing to have “rough sex” with Daly. But then she said: “Obviously our definitions of rough sex are different.”

Daly gave evidence denying that there had been any knife, and denying that the violence had taken place.

Category: News

Pin It on Pinterest